Shopping Writer Meghan has replaced a lot of her lipsticks with lip stains, but she’s now testing which of TikTok’s most viral lip stains, Wonderskin or Sacheu, are worth adding to your makeup bag
It’s no secret that I’m a huge fan of the Wonderskin Lip Stain, which I’ve reviewed in several shades already, but beauty buffs will have no doubt noticed there’s a new viral lip stain on the block – and it’s backed by several celebrities and beauty influencers, earning a place in many makeup bags. That is, of course, the Sacheu Lip Liner.
Both have gone viral online for their long-lasting pigment and easy application, but which one truly comes out on top? I’ve decided to conduct a wear test of both the Wonderskin Lip Stain and the Sacheu Lip Liner to determine which one delivers better colour and longevity, so you know which is worth your money.
The Wonderstain Lip Stain retails for £18 at Wonderskin’s website or for £17.47 on Amazon. Meanwhile, the Sacheu Lip Liner sells for £13 at Revolve or £14 at Beauty Bay.
READ MORE: Claudia Winkleman keeps her trademark tan through autumn with simple £39 purchase
READ MORE: Olivia Attwood ‘couldn’t be more in love’ with her new favourite IPL gadget with £500 off
The Sacheu long-wear lip stain is said to keep your lips in line all day and night. Infused with hyaluronic acid and vitamin E for conditioning benefits, it also nourishes your lips while working its magic.
It’s designed to blend slightly to achieve a full lip tint, or follow A-lister Billie Eilish’s routine of applying the liner ahead of the rest of her makeup, then peeling it off ten minutes or so later, revealing perfectly lined lips that last for most of the day.
Meanwhile, the Wonderskin lip stain is described as easy to use; simply apply the mask and let it sit for 10 to 30 seconds before wiping it off with a damp cloth. The result is a natural-looking lip stain that stays in place all day, even when you’re eating and drinking. It includes a number of ingredients, such as squalane, to keep lips hydrated while they stain, although many shoppers follow it up with lip balm.
In terms of packaging, both lip stains come with a doe-foot applicator, with the Sacheu Liner offering a slightly thinner and more precise doe-foot, ensuring it’s easily used as a lip liner or as an all-over colour.
While the Wonderskin’s first colour may be slightly off-putting to start, as it comes out in a blue/purple metalic shade that won’t resemble the hue you’ve picked out of the 17 shades on offer – until wiped off, that is – the Sacheu lip liner is argueably even more alarming, as it’s formula appears thick, tacky and nearly black once you open the packaging.
It is worth noting that before applying any lip stain, I recommend exfoliating your lips. Use a lip scrub or mask, as this reduces the amount of dry or cracked skin on your lips, allowing the pigment to cling to them more effectively. I’ve found that, when applied to dry or chapped lips, the colour will appear uneven or patchy, regardless of the brand used.
When it comes to application, Wonderskin’s thinner formula allows for a more seamless application, making it easier to spread evenly across the whole lip without excessive bleeding outside the lip line or transferring onto your teeth.
The Sacheu’s almost tarr-like consistency does make for a messy application; it’s not easily spreadable, and due to its tackiness, it can be somewhat difficult to get a precise line without excessive patience and delicacy. Plus, Sacheu may not be the best pick if you’re in a hurry, as the colour can (and definitely will) transfer onto your teeth, tongue and fingers, leaving stains behind. This colour transfer does come off after some time, but it’s not ideal if you’re about to head out of the house.
When it comes to the novelty ‘peel off’ design of these lip masks, Sacheu definitely comes out on top. I’ve never been able to peel off the Wonderskin lip stain and have instead opted to use a makeup wipe. However, the Sacheu Lip Liner tends to peel off nearly perfectly every time, with only the occasional patch left behind. This isn’t a deal breaker for me when it comes to the Wonderskin lip stain, as I don’t mind using a wipe, but what I will say is – despite the satisfaction of the peel off design, the Sacheu is definitely messier as the colour will transfer onto your fingers and nails, unless you use tweezers.
When it comes to colour payoff, the Wonderskin leans towards a higher level of pigment and lasts the longest. I’ve also always noticed a less patchy finish with the Wonderskin lip stain. That said, this time I tried one of the newest shades, Hush, which is described as a more neutral brown colour. However, much like my old favourite shade, Lovely, this lip stain still results in a dark pink colour that’s similar to my natural lip colour but more saturated. This is fine and I like the look, but if you’re actually looking for a more nude/brown colour, Wonderskin isn’t going to do it.
That said, Sacheu definitely delivered a more brown hue, which is my preferred everyday shade, with only twinges of pink coming through. But the Sacheu lip liner definitely does not last as long as the Wonderskin pick. I found that after a few hours (including eating and drinking), the colour was already starting to fade, while the Wonderskin lasts for well over 12 hours, sometimes lasting over 24 hours.